I personally don't mind too much about how the seasonal pet is set up, for users that buy 1 of each new item every month it's a really nice bonus to be giving us alongside what we were already getting anyways, which I think was the intention. However, I think it would be better if turnips spent in Pai's shop also counted in Agnes'? That way it can be structured like this
- month 1: buy one of each from Pai
- month 2: buy a monthly coffer from Agnes
- month 3: buy at least 5 items from Pai

Boom, guaranteed seasonal pet for a player who is getting one of each new item anyways (with some wiggle room)! As it is right now, Agne's doesn't have a 500 turnip item that feels worth it to spend on for a majority of players, even the ones who just want to complete their collection. There really isn't a need to force players to spend on something they don't want, when spending that same amount on the other shop would get them the pet within that timeframe otherwise. Especially if the pet is meant to be a bonus (which again, is what I would like to believe your intentions were) and not a 'cash grab' like others are alleging. Considering you also released a pet for free players alongside the seasonal one, it really does feel like it was something that was meant as 'we'll show our appreciation to the players committing to supporting us monetarily, and another for those who can't so that everyone feels included' but maybe that's the part of me that tries to see the good in everyone idk. I really love dappervolk and want you guys to succeed!

As for the rest of the update, the clothing is my favorite monthly set so far, and I'm excited about the winter event and other upcoming content! Please don't be discouraged, there are people who see the changes you've been making towards improving the user experience and appreciate you for it. You can't please everyone, but making compromises when possible like you guys have been trying is definitely the right direction to go!